GEN1540 Concerning the subject of
lashon hara [evil speech], our Sages, z”l, further mentioned
Arachin 15b that if a woman requests from her neighbor a burning coal from [her] hearth,
Isaiah 30:14, and she answers “Where are burning coals if not in the house of so-and-so who is always roasting and eating meat?” – this and the like are
avak lashon hara [dust of evil speech] [From the context it seems that it is
avak lashon hara because it can led to others taking advantage of so-and-so’s wealth. Cf.
Chafetz Chaim, Laws of Lashon Hara 2:2, which says that it is not
avak lashon hara unless her inflections and gestures imply negativity.] Further, the
pasuk says
Proverbs 27:14, “One who blesses his friend in a loud voice early [each] morning – it will be regarded [as] a curse to him.” Our Sages
Arachin 16a interpreted this
pasuk as referring to one who praises another with praise that leads to [financial] loss. For example, a guest goes out to the [main] city square
Esther 4:6 and calls out in a loud voice, telling about his good host’s graciousness, how he slaughtered and prepared meat [this verse] for his guest. When the guest’s words are heard, idle men will gather and go to the host’s house. [i.e., where they will take advantage of his wealth and hospitality]. GATES 435
SHOW FULL EXCERPT