Excerpt Browser

This page displays the full text of excerpts.  When viewing a single excerpt, its “Share,” “Switch Article,” and “Comment” functions are accessible.

LEVITICUS — 19:15 favor

LEV439 It is a negative commandment to show no honor to an eminent man in a court judgment as Scripture says, nor shall you favor the person of the mighty [this verse]. This means that if people come before him [a justice] in a lawsuit, one great and one small [in importance, etc.] he is not to honor the great one and is not to treat him cordially. He is not to greet that one in any greater extent than the other one.

SHOW FULL EXCERPT

LEVITICUS — 19:15 favorably

LEV443 If one sees another person say or do something--whether in the area of bein adam l’Makom (matters between man and Hashem) or in the area of bein adam l’chaveiro--interpersonal relationships--and his actions can be judged favorably and given the benefit of the doubt, then the halachah depends on how virtuous the person is. If he is G-d-fearing, then one is required to give him the benefit of the doubt even if it seems more likely that he acted improperly. If he is an average person who generally refrains from sin but does stumble on occasion, then if the possibility that he acted properly is equal to the possibility that he acted inappropriately, one is required to judge him favorably. Indeed, Chazal say, “If one judges his fellow favorably, Hashem will judge him favorably.” This obligation is included in Hashem's commandment of בְּצֶ֖דֶק תִּשְׁפֹּ֥ט עֲמִיתֶֽךָ, “Judge your fellow favorably” (Leviticus 19:15). Even if the possibility that the other person acted improperly seems to outweigh the possibility that his action was justified, it is correct to consider the matter inconclusive, rather than assume that the other person acted improperly. In a case in which it seems likely that the person's actions were indeed justified, if one judges him unfavorably-- which is certainly forbidden by halachah--and consequently proceeds to disparage him, not only does he violate the commandment of בְּצֶ֖דֶק תִּשְׁפֹּ֥ט עֲמִיתֶֽךָ, “Judge your fellow favorably,” he also transgresses the prohibition of speaking lashon hara. Even when the chances that the person acted improperly outweigh the chances that he acted properly-- in which case there would not be as much of a halachic prohibition to judge him unfavorably-- all that would mean is that the observer may assume for himself that the other person acted inappropriately. However, he may not hurry to go disparage that person before others on the basis of this assumption, unless all of the conditions delineated in sections 4, 5, and 10 are fulfilled. For even if the other person did act improperly, in many cases it would still be forbidden to disparage him, as one who studies those sections will discover.

SHOW FULL EXCERPT

LEVITICUS — 19:15 injustice

LEV445 It is a negative commandment to commit no injustice in rendering judgment as Scripture says, You shall do no injustice in judgment [this verse]. This means not to declare the guilty innocent or the innocent guilty. Included in this prohibition is the rule not to delay the verdict. After it has become evident to the judge where justice lies, if he dwells at length on clear matters in order to cause one of the litigants distress, this is in the general category of injustice.

SHOW FULL EXCERPT

LEVITICUS — 19:15 judge

LEV451 Judge all parties fairly and equally. Key concept: Ensure the smooth functioning of society. If a judge gives preferential treatment to one litigant, the other litigant might be afraid to state his claims. Or, because he feels intimidated, he might be unable to state his claims clearly. Such could cause the court to rule incorrectly. The mitzvah also applies to Torah scholars who are called upon to settle disputes to the best of their ability outside of court. Also included in this mitzvah is that all Jews must judge their fellows favorably by giving them the benefit of the doubt. That is, if someone’s acts or words can be interpreted as sinful or not sinful, one is obligated to interpret them as not sinful. Such behavior promotes peace, unity and goodwill. The main purpose of this mitzvah is to aid society by stopping people from suspecting one another.

SHOW FULL EXCERPT

RSS
First8910111213141516182021222324252627Last
Back To Top